Directly after graduating from Colby, Arthur Page spent about five years teaching. In 1903, Page decided to pursue a an education in Ministry from the Newton Theological Institute in Newton, Massachusetts. He graduated with a Bachelor of Divinity as a member of the Class of 1906.
In March of 1905, while at the Newton Theological Institute, Page submitted a Student Volunteer Movement application to become a missionary abroad. In his application, he cited reasons such as “discouragement at the usefulness of [his] life”, as well as his aptitude in foreign languages and background in education as reasons for why he wanted to go abroad to do missionary work and why he would be a good missionary abroad. One of the only reasons he was cited that he was not fit to move abroad was due to his poor health at the time of submitting the application.
In 1906, directly before moving abroad to China to begin missionary work, he married Ethel Maude Lamy, who moved to China with him for missionary work.