{"id":702,"date":"2020-04-30T20:38:13","date_gmt":"2020-05-01T00:38:13","guid":{"rendered":"http:\/\/web.colby.edu\/coronaguidance\/?p=702"},"modified":"2020-07-31T00:21:07","modified_gmt":"2020-07-31T04:21:07","slug":"islamic-burial","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/web.colby.edu\/coronaguidance\/2020\/04\/30\/islamic-burial\/","title":{"rendered":"COVID-19 and Islamic burial laws: safeguarding dignity of the dead"},"content":{"rendered":"

As the number of coronavirus (COVID-19) deaths continues to rise across all regions of the world, Ahmed Al-Dawoody, ICRC\u2019s legal advisor on Islamic law, and Oran Finegan, head of forensics for the ICRC, explain how forensic science and Islamic burial laws can safeguard dignified handling of the mortal remains of individuals who have died from the pandemic. [ICRC = International Committee of the Red Cross]<\/i><\/em><\/p>\n

Losing a loved one is one of the most difficult things we have to go through in life, even under the best of circumstances. Every culture and community has its own set of rituals to help ease the pain, from Hindus gathering to burn corpses along the Ganges River to the Jewish tradition of receiving condolences at home during a seven-day mourning period.<\/p>\n

Under Islamic law, as in many cultures and religions, the management of dead bodies is the object of specific rules that aim at ensuring the dignity and respect of the dead as well as for their living relatives. The nature and sheer scale of the current coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic, however, has created a number of questions, challenges and even rumours in Muslim-majority states as well as for Muslim communities around the globe.<\/p>\n

Humanitarian organizations such as the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) have developed experience and specialized expertise in crisis management and emergency response, medical care in detention, and humanitarian forensics. This experience is accumulated from more than 150 years of operating in conflict zones and from an operational presence in more than 90 countries, positioning the ICRC to provide valuable guidance and assist state authorities and non-state armed groups (NSAGs) in the response to the COVID-19 pandemic.<\/p>\n

On the basis of this experience, this article offers expertise on one of the humanitarian challenges caused by the COVID-19 crisis: how Islamic burial laws can be referenced and adapted to the numerous protection challenges in Muslim contexts for a more dignified handling of mortal remains.<\/p>\n

Islamic burial laws: protecting life, first and foremost<\/strong><\/h2>\n

According to Islamic tradition, the burial of a deceased person is a collective obligation (fard\u0323 kifa\u0304yah<\/i>) by the Muslim community. This obligation consists of\u00a0ghusl<\/i>, ritual washing of dead bodies,\u00a0kafan<\/i>, or shrouding the body with pieces of cloth and finally\u00a0salat al-janazah<\/i>, a funeral prayer.<\/p>\n

In handling the remains of COVID-19 victims, whether in Muslim or non-Muslim majority states, Islamic rules developed by Muslim jurists and Islamic authorities must be guided by two considerations:<\/p>\n

First, the lives of body handlers and rest of the community must not be endangered. The protection of life (hif\u1e93 al-nafs<\/i>) is the first of the five ultimate objectives of Islamic law (maqa\u0304\u1e63id<\/i>\u00a0al-shar\u012b\u02bbah<\/i>) and therefore overrides any other Islamic obligations. It is therefore of paramount importance to keep in mind, as discussed below, that determining the Islamic position on any of these three Islamic burial laws for the victims of COVID-19 is dependent on the available medical evidence of how such a practice could put a life at risk.<\/p>\n

Second, according to Islamic burial rituals, the dignity of the dead and the emotions of their loved ones are to be respected as much as is practically possible in extraordinary situations such as armed conflicts, epidemics, disasters or other catastrophes. This pragmatic approach is characteristic of Islamic law, as evidenced in the Islamic legal maxims[1]<\/a>\u00a0pertinent to the COVID-19 pandemic:<\/p>\n

    \n
  1. Harm must be removed (al-\u1e0darar yuz\u0101l<\/i>);<\/li>\n
  2. Hardship begets ease (Al-mashaqqah tajlib al-tays\u012br<\/i>);<\/li>\n
  3. Necessity lifts prohibitions\/makes the unlawful lawful (Al-\u1e0dar\u016br\u0101t tub\u012b\u1e25 al-ma\u1e25\u1e93\u016br\u0101t<\/i>);<\/li>\n
  4. Necessity is measured according to its proportion (Al-\u1e0darurah tuqaddar biqadariha<\/i>); and<\/li>\n
  5. Matters shall be judged by their objectives (Al-um\u016br bimaqa\u0304\u1e63idh\u0101<\/i>).<\/li>\n<\/ol>\n

    Current Islamic burial practices in both Muslim and non-Muslim majority states must be shaped by the available medical evidence and forensic guidelines. However, to date, the medical knowledge and scientific evidence related to the COVID-19 pandemic are incomplete. The guidance provided by Islamic and health authorities in Muslim-majority states and Islamic organizations in the West therefore differ with regard to the three core Islamic burial laws:<\/p>\n

    Ritual washing (ghusl)<\/i><\/h3>\n

    \"ICRC<\/a>The required\u00a0ghusl<\/i>, or ritual washing of the body, can be performed as normal for COVID-19 victims, provided that the necessary protective measures are put in place. Forensic guidance includes wearing complete Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) \u2013 including gloves, gown, a waterproof apron, face shield and goggles, and a mask \u2013 as well as avoiding direct contact with blood or bodily fluids, making sure that wounds are covered with waterproof bandages, and avoiding contact with the face and mouth, as well as food, drink, or eating and drinking utensils.<\/p>\n

    To date,\u00a0ghusl\u00a0<\/i>has been administered on the bodies of COVID-19 victims in most cases, as for example in Egypt,\u00a0the UK<\/a>\u00a0or Canada. The most detailed procedural guide on the burial of COVID-19 Muslim victims has been issued by the\u00a0Canadian Council of Imams<\/a>\u00a0and the Muslim Medical Association of Canada. Another guiding manual has just been released by Al-Azhar Global Fatwa Center.<\/p>\n

    If health authorities conclude that normal\u00a0ghusl,<\/i>\u00a0which includes scrubbing the body of the deceased person, could lead to infection, then merely pouring or just spraying water onto the body is sufficient. This was confirmed by Jordanian Iftaa Board\u00a0Resolution No. 283<\/a>, issued on 19 March 2020 and typifying the pragmatic and practical Islamic approach to the issue under discussion. The resolution makes clear that all necessary protective measures must be taken to prevent infection and that as much as possible of the burial rituals shall be performed provided that no infection can be transmitted. Otherwise, merely spraying water on the body and shrouding will suffice.<\/p>\n

    The Ministry of Health in Morocco has also issued instructions for the handling of dead bodies of confirmed or potential COVID-19 victims, stating that \u2018the ritual of washing the body, whether at the hospital morgue or the city morgue, must be supervised by the local management team (reducing to a minimum the use of water, spraying and other rituals used)\u2019. Afterwards, all areas used should be disinfected, including trolleys and tables, and disposable objects should be treated as medical waste.<\/p>\n

    If spraying water could also lead to infection, then dry purification, or\u00a0tayammum<\/i><\/a>,\u00a0<\/i>should be performed. Both Iran\u2019s Supreme Guide, Ali Khamenei and his eminence Al-Sayyid Ali Al-Husseini Al-Sistani, the prominent Shi\u2018\u0304\u012b authorities, have issued recent\u00a0fatwas<\/a>\u00a0to this effect.<\/p>\n

    If none of the above is permitted by the health authorities, as is the case for example in Algeria, France and Tunisia, then the body should be buried\u00a0without\u00a0ghusl<\/i>\u00a0or\u00a0tayammum<\/i><\/a>. This is not a new Islamic position. In fact, premodern Muslim jurists permitted burials without performing\u00a0ghusl<\/i>\u00a0in cases where the high number of bodies resulting from an epidemic would make it impossible.[2]<\/a><\/p>\n

    Shrouding (kafan)<\/i>
    \n<\/strong><\/h3>\n

    \"ICRC<\/a>Following the same approach as with\u00a0ghusl<\/i>, shrouding shall be done only if there is no risk of infection. In his\u00a0fatwa<\/a>\u00a0on 27 March 2020 regarding the burial of those who have died from COVID-19, Ayatollah Al-Sistani proclaimed that the three layers of shroud could wrap the body even from outside the body bag and, if that is not possible, then a single shroud could cover the whole body.<\/p>\n

    Funeral prayer (salat al-gh\u0101\u2019ib<\/i>)
    \n<\/strong><\/h3>\n

    \"ICRC<\/a>The funeral prayer requirement should not constitute an issue in the context of COVID-19 because it can be performed by a minimum of two individuals. Furthermore, funeral prayers can be performed at the grave after the burial of the dead. Alternatively, absentee funeral prayers (salat al-gh\u0101\u2019ib<\/i>) can be performed on COVID-19 victims, as advocated in a recent fatwa issued during a Facebook\u00a0live session<\/a>\u00a0by Sheikh Ahmad Wisam, the Secretary of Fatwa at Dar al-Ifta in Egypt.<\/p>\n

    Most Muslim-majority states have closed mosques and advised that funeral prayers should be performed in open spaces or cemeteries. They have also\u00a0advised<\/a>\u00a0keeping the number of those who perform the funeral prayer on the COVID-19 victims to a minimum and ensuring that burial can be carried out\u00a0on the same day<\/a>.<\/p>\n

    Protection challenges<\/strong><\/h2>\n

    There are several protection challenges in Muslim contexts that the COVID-19 pandemic poses for the humanitarian community. These require a transversal inter- and intra-disciplinary approach.<\/p>\n

    Denying burial of COVID-19 victims<\/strong><\/h3>\n

    The refusal to bury the mortal remains of COVID-19 victims is due to the misperception that corpses could spread infection in nearby population centers. These types of rumours led Dr Ahmed al-Tayyeb (the Grand Imam of Al-Azhar, the highest religious authority in the Sunni world) and Dr. Shawki Allam (the Grand Mufti of Egypt) to issue\u00a0statements<\/a>\u00a0condemning and prohibiting this practice.<\/p>\n

    This illustrates the need for strengthened cooperation between authorities, Islamic institutions and humanitarian organizations \u2013 more specifically, humanitarian forensics experts \u2013 to ensure a dignified burial of the dead. Dissemination and communication is crucial, both on the relevant scientific evidence as well as the fact that burying the dead as a collective obligation (fard\u0323 kifa\u0304yah<\/i>) in Islam means that the entire Muslim community would be guilty if they failed to fulfil this communal duty.<\/p>\n

    Collective graves<\/strong><\/h3>\n

    While Islamic law provides that every dead body should be buried in an individual grave, Muslim jurists agree that, in case of necessity such as armed conflicts or disasters, collective graves are permitted. Male and female bodies should be buried in separate graves, but if necessity dictates otherwise, classical Muslim jurists stipulate that a barrier of dust should be placed between the bodies.<\/p>\n

    Classical Muslim jurists also agree that Muslims and non-Muslims should be buried in separate graves.[3]<\/a>\u00a0However, in situations where the religious identity of bodies is unknown, Muslim jurists have disagreed as to whether they should be buried in Muslim or non-Muslim graves or whether they should be buried in special graves that do not belong to either the Muslim or the non-Muslim graves. This practice of burying the dead in separate graves based on religious identity is still observed in some Muslim-majority states and can hinder the dignified burial of unidentified dead bodies if there are no graves allocated for non-Muslim bodies.<\/p>\n

    Cremation<\/strong><\/h3>\n

    In Islamic law and Muslim cultures, burying the dead in the ground is regarded as the correct way of respecting dead bodies, while cremation is prohibited because it is considered a violation of the dignity of the human body.[4]<\/a>\u00a0Cremation of the remains of individuals that have died from COVID-19 has therefore been a great concern for Muslim communities in some non-Muslim majority states.<\/p>\n

    In the UK, the government has\u00a0amended<\/a>\u00a0an emergency COVID-19 bill to stop cremation against the wishes of Muslim and Jewish families, since cremation is strictly prohibited in both faiths. In Sri Lanka, the Muslim community\u00a0appealed<\/a>\u00a0on 26 March 2020 to President Gotabaya Rajapaksa to stop the cremation of COVID-19 Muslim victims. On 3 April 2020, Amnesty International expressed\u00a0concern<\/a>\u00a0that \u2018religious tensions could be inflamed if Muslim families not allowed to bury relatives in accordance with religious practice\u2019, noting that two of the early COVID-19 victims belonging to the Muslim faith were \u2018forcibly cremated on the instructions of the authorities and against the wishes of the deceased\u2019s families\u2019.<\/p>\n

    The World Health Organization\u2019s\u00a0guidance<\/a>\u00a0on infection prevention and control for the safe management of bodies in the context of COVID-19 shines a clear light on the debate, stating that \u2018To date there is no evidence of persons having become infected from exposure to the bodies of persons who died from COVID-19\u2019. However, a low risk does still exist from the aerosolization of fluids from the body, a risk that is greater for health care and death care workers who may be involved in the examination of a dead body or the cleaning of a mortuary area following autopsy.<\/p>\n

    Challenges for death care workers and the forensic community<\/strong><\/h3>\n

    The impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic will be felt by the forensic community for many years to come. Its scale has had a devastating impact on health and death care workers, leaving all involved overwhelmed and desperate for a response to match the strength of the virus and the resulting pandemic. There is a need for greater coordination between those actors involved and for clearer messaging for communities affected.<\/p>\n

    The ICRC, like many institutions, has worked to develop guidance on COVID-19 for its teams \u2013 and for all those working on tackling the pandemic \u2013 to help dispel misinformation that has been increasingly filling the gaps of knowledge about the virus and its effects. From the onset of the crisis, we found ourselves confronted with a sea of information and guidance, some aligned and substantiated, some less so. From questions surrounding the level of contagion of the virus from the dead to the living, to what type or level of PPE is required for handling dead bodies, the ICRC finds itself still confronted by much of the same lack of clarity that existed only a month ago.<\/p>\n

    While there will always be some degree of disagreement within the scientific community, especially at such an early stage when much of the needed research is still ongoing, we must ask ourselves if there is more that could have and still can be done in the coming weeks and months to align globally messaging more coherently between different agencies.<\/p>\n

    Until then, we can at least agree that there are serious issues regarding a lack of preparedness for emergency planning at national and regional level, and major issues over a lack of adherence to health and safety procedures in many institutions where the dead are managed. These shortcomings have been very much exposed by the current pandemic and beg the question of whether these lessons will be learned for future scenarios.<\/p>\n

    We also see the role the media, in particular social media, has played in bringing to our attention instances of suspected mismanagement of the dead. The speed at which these stories have hit us has left little time for a full analysis of the validity of claims, reinforcing the need for clear messaging on the risks and the myths surrounding the current outbreak. The ICRC Forensic Unit, in cooperation with other departments internally, has worked to develop key messages targeting decision makers, practitioners, and affected communities themselves. Awareness-raising and coherent messaging can play an important role, in collaboration with other agencies, to reassure concerned communities at a time when they are at their most vulnerable.<\/p>\n

    For example,\u00a0clear messaging<\/a>\u00a0in social media, as outlined by Islamic law experts, on the Islamic burial laws in the case of COVID-19 is an important example of how such messaging matters. Our experience from dealing with the dead in large-scale disasters has shown how the failure to act and provide quick, coherent messages dispelling common myths can have a serious negative impact on mitigating the risk of panic mass burials and mistreatment of the dead. The impact of these actions on the families of those who have died can be devastating, and only goes to further undermine the dignity of the dead themselves.<\/p>\n

    We also forget the impact the handling of the dead can have on untrained or unprepared volunteers, drafted in to deal with the dead when the system can no longer cope. The long-term impact on such individuals is something that warrants urgent research.<\/p>\n

    Finally, we need to remember that we live in a world of amazing diversity and richness of culture and religion. The treatment of the dead in line with these important traditions must not be forgotten. To do otherwise only further undermines their dignity and the needs of the affected community. In the case of Islam, we must seek guidance from those Islamic scholars and religious and community leaders who can best guide us, and work together with them to define a response that speaks to those who this pandemic is affecting. This will help ensure that the response implemented is the one that brings reassurance and comfort to the affected community as a whole, while respecting health and safety concerns.<\/p>\n

    Conclusion
    \n<\/strong><\/h2>\n

    Islamic burial laws and instructions from health authorities in Muslim-majority states are considerably and continuously shaped by the available medical evidence and forensic guidelines, demonstrating that Islamic law is able to adapt to the reality of handling the remains of people who have died from COVID-19. In other words, it is realistic to follow authorities\u2019 medical and forensic instructions while also respecting Islamic burial laws.<\/p>\n

    Nonetheless, handling the remains of COVID-19 victims could aggravate this global crisis if adequate coordination between health authorities, humanitarian forensics and Islamic religious authorities does not take place and if guidance on the burial of the COVID-19 Muslim victims is not communicated and explained to the Muslim public through local imams, the media, and community leaders \u2013 a scenario that will allow misconceptions and rumours to persist.<\/p>\n

    In the Islamic legislative process, Muslim jurists use certain Islamic sources and legal tools to develop laws regulating the handling of remains of individuals who have died from COVID-19, guided by the objectives of preventing individual and communal harm and maintaining the dignity of the dead. To fulfil these objectives, humanitarian forensic scientists, protection, communication and networking delegates require basic understanding of the above Islamic positions, the Islamic legal system, its sources and legal tools \u2013 coupled with an awareness of the different practices in various Muslim cultures and contexts \u2013 \u00a0that will help them to communicate key messages and facilitate discussions on common ground using a culturally sensitive approach.<\/p>\n

    [1]<\/a>\u00a0On Islamic legal maxims, see for example, Luqman Zakariyah,\u00a0Legal Maxims in Islamic Criminal Law: Theory and Applications<\/i>\u00a0(Brill Nijhoff: Leiden; Boston: 2015).<\/p>\n

    [2]<\/a>\u00a0See \u02bbAbd Allah ibn Najm al-Khallal,\u00a0\u02bbIqd al-Jawa\u0304hir al-Tham\u012bnah f\u012b madhhab \u02bba\u0304lim al-Mad\u012bnah<\/i>, ed. Mohammad \u02bbUthm\u0101n, (Beirut: D\u0101r al-Kutub al-\u02bbIlmiyyah, 2010), pp. 236-237.<\/p>\n

    [3]<\/a>\u00a0Ahmed Al-Dawoody, \u201cManagement of the dead from the Islamic law and international humanitarian law perspectives: Considerations for humanitarian forensics,\u201d\u00a0International Review of the Red Cross<\/i>, (2017), 99 (2), pp. 769\u2013770.<\/p>\n

    [4]<\/a>\u00a0On the Islamic position on cremation in general and a fatwa by the current Grand Mufti of Egypt on the cremation of the dead bodies of Ebola victims, see\u00a0Ibid<\/i>., p. 774.<\/p>\n

    See also<\/h3>\n